We were discussing indecency regulation in conlaw today… the exact topic my paper is on. It seems almost the entire class feels that the dirty words in the Carlin monologue are perfectly valid in every day civil conversation, and to ban them “turns the First Amendment on its head.” I tried my best to argue the other way, but I was faced with a number of shaking heads and responses filled with scorn and derision.
After class, as I was back in my dorm waiting for the elevator, I ran into a classmate. She’s cute — I have long had a mini crush on her. “Interesting class,” she said. She smiled at me, but it was an empty smile. She shook her head. “I disagree with basically everything you said.”
The elevator arrived and we walked in. She was going to the fifth floor — I had about 10 seconds to explain my position.
“Those words are never needed in everyday conversation,” I said. “You never hear them in law school. You never hear them unless we are specifically discussing a case that has to do with those words.”
I was going to talk about how some people find fuck and shit and cunt offensive. I was going to say that they coarsen discourse. I was going to say that when people claim First Amendment protections for indecency, it cheapens the meaning of the First Amendment.
She cut me off. “I use those words all the time in my speech. And as an artist, expression is important to me. What about Chris Rock — would his routine be as funny without those words? I want to be able to hear that.”
The elevator stopped on her floor; the door opened. I had about three seconds.
“I agree,” I said. “But should it be on TV at 2 in the afternoon when eight year old kids can hear it?”
Her response was immediate, her tone dismissive: “Sure. Eight year olds should hear that. If they can’t handle it…”
Her voice trailed off. She turned and walked away. My memory flashed on the Chris Rock monologue; snippets ran through my head. “Put the dick down”; “Fee fi fo figger, boy I hate a nigger”… an eight year old should hear that? He wouldn’t know what to do with it, what to make of it. If he were exposed to that kind of language on a constant basis, he would be coarsened. I don’t know why the prospect troubles me so; it just does, it shakes me, and I can’t brush it off. I don’t want to hear indecency in my home as I flick through the channels. I don’t want my kids to hear that.
What is wrong with people, I think, defeated. What is wrong with society?